Understanding the World: The Evolution of Numeracy: Cognitive Foundations, Tools, and the Role of Language
Is it cheating to use a calculator? Is it cheating to use AI?
Note: This essay was prepared with the research assistance of AI and the ghostwriting of AI. No AIs were harmed in this process.
Author's Preface
I am going to discuss numeracy1 and its development in evolutionary terms. I take a few side trips in the process, and discuss using calculators as a tool, and AI as a tool, among a whole lot more. Yes, I do ramble on. Forgive me, I am getting old and my mind wanders.
In recent discussions about the role of AI in creative endeavours, a common concern has been the potential devaluation of work produced with the aid of these advanced tools. Critics argue that using AI for tasks like writing, composing music, or generating art is somehow lazy or inappropriate, suggesting that it diminishes the value of the final product. However, I would like to challenge this perspective by emphasizing the distinction between process and product.
The process refers to the method or tools used to create something, whether it's performing arithmetic by hand, using a calculator, or employing AI to assist in writing or composing. The product, on the other hand, is the final outcome of that process—a piece of writing, a musical composition, or a mathematical solution. It's crucial to understand that the quality or value of the product is not inherently tied to the process used to create it. A song written with the help of AI can be just as moving, or even more so, than one created entirely by human effort. Similarly, an article written with AI assistance can be insightful and well-crafted, regardless of the tools used in its creation.
Many of us who grew up learning arithmetic spent hours memorizing multiplication tables and mastering various methods of calculation. Yet today, we readily use calculators—whether on dedicated devices or smartphones—to perform these tasks. We don't see this as lazy; instead, it's considered an efficient use of tools. The same logic applies to AI in creative fields. AI is simply another tool, one that, like any other, requires learning and understanding to use effectively. The real issue isn't whether AI is used, but how well it's used.
There is also a widespread misconception that creativity is limited to the arts—music, literature, painting—while fields like mathematics and science are seen as purely logical or analytical. This is far from the truth. Mathematics, for instance, is deeply creative, involving the invention of new ways to solve problems, the discovery of patterns, and the construction of elegant proofs. Science, too, requires creativity in devising experiments, interpreting data, and developing theories.
Having some very minor credentials in both scientific research and mathematical exploration, as well as in songwriting and music composition, I can attest to the creative nature of these endeavors. Whether the product is a piece of music, a mathematical proof, or a scientific paper, the creative process behind it is very much the same. To those who question the use of AI in creative work, I would say: the focus should be on the quality of the product, not the process used to achieve it. Creativity is not confined to the arts; it is a fundamental part of all human intellectual activity, and AI is just another tool to help us explore it. Using AI is just lazy? Give your head a shake.
Finally, it's important to acknowledge that cognitive operations supporting numeracy are just as mysterious as any other aspect of thinking in humans and animals. Language, consciousness, logic, symbolic reasoning, abstraction—all of these remain deeply enigmatic. At our current stage of evolution, we barely understand these processes. While we have gained a few insights from neurology, these are just that—little hints at the vast complexity of cognitive functions that continue to elude our full comprehension.
Introduction
Numeracy, broadly defined as the ability to understand and work with numbers, has a complex evolutionary history that intertwines animal instincts, human cognitive development, the evolution of language, and the creation of tools to enhance numerical understanding. This essay explores how numeracy has evolved, from its primitive origins in animals to its sophisticated manifestations in human society. We will examine the mental operations fundamental to numeracy, the development of notational systems and tools—from early writing systems to modern digital technologies—and the critical role of language in advancing numerical thought. This discussion includes a detailed look at how these elements have shaped numeracy over time, with clear distinctions between what is supported by evidence and what remains speculative.
Cognitive Foundations of Numeracy
Mental Operations Fundamental to Numeracy
The development of numeracy is rooted in a variety of mental operations that are essential to both human and animal cognition. These operations include:
Measurement:
Explanation: Measurement involves assessing the size, length, or amount of something relative to a standard unit. It is a fundamental cognitive operation seen in both animals and humans, though humans have refined it into a complex system with precise tools and standardized units.
Evidence: Primates, for example, can estimate distances and sizes to some extent, demonstrating a basic form of measurement (Stevens & Hauser, 2004).
Counting:
Explanation: Counting is the process of determining the number of items in a set. This operation is foundational to numeracy and is seen in both animals and humans, although in a more developed form in humans.
Evidence: Birds and primates have demonstrated the ability to count small numbers of objects, which suggests an evolutionary basis for this ability (Dehaene, 2011).
Sequencing:
Explanation: Sequencing involves arranging items or events in a specific order, often based on a rule or pattern. It is essential for understanding processes and the relationships between items.
Evidence: Human infants learn to sequence objects by size or number, and similar behaviors are observed in animals, such as nest-building in birds (Piaget, 1952).
Sorting or Ordering:
Explanation: Sorting involves categorizing items based on specific criteria, while ordering involves arranging items in a ranked sequence. Both operations are critical for organizing information.
Evidence: Sorting and ordering are fundamental cognitive tasks, seen in human activities like organizing objects by size or color, and also in animal behavior such as food sorting (Rosati et al., 2007).
Summarizing:
Explanation: Summarizing is the ability to condense information into a more concise form by identifying key points or patterns. This operation is important for abstract thinking and problem-solving.
Speculation: Summarizing is primarily a human cognitive skill, and while animals may recognize and prioritize patterns, this remains speculative and less developed.
Logical Connections:
Explanation: Logical connections involve understanding the relationships between different ideas or pieces of information, often in the form of cause and effect or conditions and consequences. This is central to mathematical reasoning.
Speculation: While humans excel at complex logical reasoning, simple cause-and-effect understanding is also observed in animals (Premack & Woodruff, 1978).
Categorizing and Subclassifying:
Explanation: Categorizing involves grouping items based on shared characteristics, while subclassifying involves creating subgroups within those categories. These operations are essential for organizing knowledge and understanding complex systems.
Evidence: Categorization is a universal cognitive skill, seen in both humans and animals, with pigeons being able to categorize objects based on visual similarities (Lazareva et al.,2006)..
Estimating:
Explanation: Estimating involves making an educated guess about a quantity or outcome, important for decision-making when precise measurement is not possible.
Evidence: Estimation is observed in many animals, such as when predators assess the number of prey or judge the distance to a target (Feigenson et al., 2004).
Speculation on the Evolution of Mental Operations
While there is substantial evidence for these mental operations in both humans and animals, the evolutionary pathways that led to their development are not fully understood. It is speculated that these abilities evolved due to the survival advantages they provided, such as better resource management and improved social coordination. The refinement of these operations in humans likely accelerated with the advent of language and culture, allowing for more complex and abstract forms of reasoning.
The Role of Language in Refining Numeracy
The Necessity of Language for Advanced Numerical Skills
Language plays a crucial role in advancing numeracy beyond basic capabilities. It allows for the expression and manipulation of abstract concepts that are difficult to grasp without symbolic representation.
Abstract Concepts: Language enables humans to articulate and work with abstract mathematical ideas, such as zero, infinity, and negative numbers, which are central to advanced mathematics (Butterworth, 1999).
Complex Calculations: The ability to perform complex calculations relies heavily on the manipulation of symbols, which is deeply rooted in linguistic structures (Dehaene, 2011).
Logical Reasoning: Language provides the framework for expressing and manipulating logical connections, essential for problem-solving and mathematical proofs (Kline, 1972).
Speculation on Language and Cognitive Development
The relationship between language and cognitive development remains a subject of ongoing research. While it is clear that language enhances numerical cognition, it is speculative how early humans transitioned from non-linguistic numeracy to the symbolic and language-based systems we use today. It is likely that the evolution of language and numeracy were mutually reinforcing.
The Evolution of Tools for Numeracy
Historical Development of Numerical Tools
Throughout history, humans have developed various tools to aid in counting, measuring, and calculating, which reflect and influence the development of numerical thought.
Early Counting Tools: Tools like fingers, pebbles, and rocks were among the first used for counting. These simple aids allowed early humans to track quantities and perform basic arithmetic operations.
Writing Systems and Notational Tools: The invention of writing systems like cuneiform and hieroglyphics, and the development of notational tools such as clay tablets, styluses, and later pens and paper, allowed for the recording and transmission of numerical information. This enabled the externalization of complex calculations and the preservation of mathematical knowledge, allowing societies to accumulate and transmit knowledge across generations (Goody, 1986).
Chalkboards, Whiteboards, and Flipcharts: These tools have become essential in educational and professional environments, especially in fields like mathematics, where they facilitate the visualization of complex formulas and ideas. The ability to easily erase and modify equations encourages iterative problem-solving and collaborative work. The joke among STEM2 folks—writing a complex equation on a chalkboard and filling in the gap with "and then some miracle happens"—highlights the sometimes mysterious leap from problem to solution in creative mathematical thinking (Drake, 1989).
PowerPoint and Digital Presentation Tools: Modern digital tools like PowerPoint have revolutionized the way numerical information is presented and shared. These tools allow for the integration of text, images, graphs, and animations, making it easier to communicate complex ideas visually and interactively. PowerPoint and similar tools have become indispensable in both educational settings and professional presentations.
Abacus and Mechanical Devices: The abacus, an ancient tool still used in some parts of the world, allows users to perform arithmetic operations quickly and efficiently. Mechanical devices like card sorters and adding machines, developed in the 19th and early 20th centuries, laid the groundwork for modern computing by automating basic numerical tasks. These tools represent significant milestones in the evolution of numeracy, enabling more complex calculations to be performed more efficiently (Swade, 2000).
Digital Computers and Mathematical Software: The advent of digital computers in the 20th century marked a significant leap in the evolution of numeracy. Computers allowed for the processing of vast amounts of data and the execution of complex mathematical operations that would be impossible to perform manually. Mathematical software like Maple and Wolfram Mathematica further extended these capabilities, enabling advanced symbolic and numerical computation (Wolfram, 2020).
AI and Advanced Computational Tools: AI systems represent the latest development in the evolution of numeracy tools. These systems can perform tasks like pattern recognition, data analysis, and even theorem proving, pushing the boundaries of what is possible in mathematics and other fields. While AI is still a developing technology, its potential to transform how we approach numerical problems is immense, though its full implications remain speculative.
Speculation on the Future of Numerical Tools
The future of numerical tools is likely to be shaped by ongoing advances in AI, quantum computing, and other emerging technologies. These tools may enable entirely new forms of calculation and problem-solving, potentially leading to breakthroughs in fields ranging from mathematics to artificial intelligence itself. However, the full impact of these developments is still speculative, as the technology is in its early stages and its future trajectory remains uncertain.
Refinement of Measurement in Humans
Measurement has evolved from basic perceptual judgments in animals to highly sophisticated systems in human societies. The refinement of measurement has been critical to the development of science, engineering, and mathematics.
Historical Development of Measurement
Early Human Measurement: Early humans likely relied on body parts (e.g., hands, feet) and simple tools (e.g., sticks, stones) to measure distances, quantities, and time. These methods were practical but imprecise, often varying from person to person or culture to culture.
Standardization: The development of standardized units of measurement, such as the cubit in ancient Egypt or the foot in various ancient cultures, allowed for greater precision and consistency in trade, construction, and other activities. This standardization was essential for the growth of civilizations and the development of more complex engineering projects (Cardarelli, 2003).
Scientific Measurement: The invention of more sophisticated measuring tools, such as the compass, sextant, and microscope, enabled humans to measure with unprecedented accuracy. These tools laid the foundation for modern science and engineering by allowing for precise observations and calculations (Kline, 1972).
Modern Instruments: Today, measurement has been refined to an extraordinary degree, with tools capable of measuring at atomic scales, across vast distances, and even in extreme environments like outer space or the deep ocean. The development of instruments like the laser interferometer, atomic clock, and electron microscope has revolutionized our ability to understand the universe at both the macro and micro levels.
The Development of Notational Systems
Notational systems are a critical aspect of numeracy, providing the symbols and structures needed to represent numbers, operations, and relationships in a clear and consistent way. The development of these systems has been essential for the advancement of mathematics and related fields.
Historical Development of Notational Systems
Early Numerals: The earliest known numerical notations, such as those found in Sumerian cuneiform or Egyptian hieroglyphs, were used primarily for record-keeping in trade, agriculture, and taxation. These systems were often cumbersome and limited in their ability to represent complex calculations (Robson, 2008).
Positional Notation: The development of positional notation, where the value of a digit depends on its position within a number (e.g., the decimal system), was a major breakthrough in the history of numeracy. This system, which originated in India and was later transmitted to the Islamic world and Europe, made it possible to perform arithmetic operations more efficiently and laid the groundwork for modern mathematics (Ifrah, 2000).
Algebraic Notation: The introduction of symbols to represent unknowns and operations (e.g., x, +, =) in the work of Islamic and European mathematicians like al-Khwarizmi and Descartes was a significant advancement. Algebraic notation allowed for the generalization of mathematical principles and the solving of equations, which are fundamental to all higher mathematics (Kline, 1972).
Modern Mathematical Notation: The notational systems used today in mathematics, including calculus, set theory, and logic, have evolved over centuries. These systems are designed to be both precise and flexible, allowing for the expression of complex ideas in a compact and standardized form. The development of these notations has been critical to the advancement of science and technology (Krantz, 2007).
Summary
The evolution of numeracy is a multifaceted narrative that encompasses animal instincts, human cognitive development, the evolution of language, and the creation of tools to enhance numerical understanding. From basic mental operations observed in animals to the sophisticated mathematical theories and technologies of today, numeracy has grown in response to human needs and challenges. Language has played a crucial role in this evolution, enabling the abstraction and communication of increasingly complex numerical concepts. As new tools and technologies continue to emerge, the boundaries of numeracy will likely expand further, driven by both our cognitive capacities and the cultural demands of an ever-changing world.
Bibliography
Butterworth, B. (1999). The Mathematical Brain. Macmillan. https://www.scirp.org/reference/referencespapers?referenceid=2048619
Cardarelli, F. (2003). Encyclopaedia of Scientific Units, Weights, and Measures: Their SI Equivalences and Origins. Springer. https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-1-4471-0003-4
Dehaene, S. (2011). The Number Sense: How the Mind Creates Mathematics (2nd ed.). Oxford University Press. https://www.amazon.ca/Number-Sense-Creates-Mathematics-Revised/dp/0199753873
Drake, S. (1989). Galileo at Work: His Scientific Biography. University of Chicago Press. https://archive.org/details/galileoatwork00stil
Feigenson, L., Dehaene, S., & Spelke, E. (2004). Core systems of number. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 8(7), 307-314. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15242690/
Goody, J. (1986). The Logic of Writing and the Organization of Society. Cambridge University Press. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/logic-of-writing-and-the-organization-of-society/A58ECF96A6302FDC7972E713BDE5568D
Ifrah, G. (2000). The Universal History of Numbers: From Prehistory to the Invention of the Computer. John Wiley & Sons. https://ia600205.us.archive.org/28/items/TheUniversalHistoryOfNumbers/212027005-The-Universal-History-of-Numbers_text.pdf
Kline, M. (1972). Mathematical Thought from Ancient to Modern Times. Oxford University Press. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/mathematical-thought-from-ancient-to-modern-times-volume-1-9780195061352
Krantz, S. G. (2007). The Elements of Advanced Mathematics. CRC Press. https://www.academia.edu/37389460/Krantz_The_Elements_of_Advanced_Mathematics_4e_
Premack, D., & Woodruff, G. (1978). Does the chimpanzee have a theory of mind? Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 1(4), 515-526. https://psycnet.apa.org/record/1980-27250-001
Robson, E. (2008). Mathematics in Ancient Iraq: A Social History. Princeton University Press. https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691091822/mathematics-in-ancient-iraq?srsltid=AfmBOorP4moZG8xI9Vd2fC2eCMye_NJ2yYPEVFwyUu_13tgb-1NwF7pL
Rosati, A. G., Stevens, J. R., Hare, B., & Hauser, M. D. (2007). The evolutionary origins of human patience: Temporal preferences in chimpanzees, bonobos, and human adults. Current Biology, 17(19), 1663-1668. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1517&context=psychfacpub
Stevens, J. R., & Hauser, M. D. (2004). Why be nice? Psychological constraints on the evolution of cooperation. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 8(2), 60-65. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1541&context=psychfacpub
Swade, D. (2000). The Difference Engine: Charles Babbage and the Quest to Build the First Computer. Viking. https://www.amazon.ca/Difference-Engine-Doron-Swade/dp/0142001449
Lazareva, O., Vecera, S. P., & Wasserman, E. (2006). Object discrimination in pigeons: Effects of local and global cues. Vision Research, 46(8-9), 1361-1374. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.visres.2005.11.006
Wolfram, S. (2020). A New Kind of Science. Wolfram Media. https://www.wolframscience.com/nks/
Numeracy is the ability to understand, work with, and apply numerical concepts. It encompasses a range of skills, including basic arithmetic (like addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division), as well as more advanced mathematical operations. Numeracy also involves the capacity to interpret and analyze quantitative data, understand mathematical concepts in various contexts, and solve problems that involve numbers.
In a broader sense, numeracy is akin to literacy, but in the context of numbers and mathematical concepts. Just as literacy involves reading and writing, numeracy involves the comprehension and application of mathematical ideas. It is essential for everyday tasks, such as budgeting, cooking, or understanding statistics in the news.
The development of numeracy begins early in life and is fundamental for functioning effectively in society, where numerical information is pervasive.
STEM stands for Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics. It refers to an interdisciplinary approach to education and careers that combines these four fields to foster critical thinking, problem-solving, and innovation. STEM education aims to prepare individuals for modern, technology-driven environments by developing skills essential for advancing science and industry.