Crosspost: Notes on consciousness. (XI)

Why large language models are not conscious

“This is an important preamble: a lot has been said and written about consciousness, what it means, what it takes for something to be conscious, etc. Answers to these questions are not to be found in current AI research but in the philosophy literature, and whether a program produces convincing answers to questions, or can correctly categorize images, bears very little relevance to any of these discussions. A corollary is that AI engineering skills provide no particular authority on the subject of AI consciousness, and indeed, as far as I can tell, many arguments we hear in the AI community on this subject tend be rather naïve, or at least not original and with known weaknesses.” — Romain Brette, Theoretical Neuroscience

Notes on consciousness. (XI) Why large language models are not conscious

The current discussions about AI are plagued with anthropomorphism. Of course, the name “artificial intelligence” has probably something to do with the matter. A conscious artificial intelligence might sound like science-fiction, but a sentient statistical model certainly sounds a bit more bizarre. In this post, I want to address the following question: are large language models (LLM), such as ChatGPT, or more generally deep learning models, conscious? (perhaps just a little bit?)